The Enforceability Question
Since the Supreme Court ruling in ParkingEye v Beavis (2015) and the introduction of POFA 2012, private parking fines can be enforceable — but only under certain conditions. The answer to "can they enforce this?" depends on whether the operator has followed all the required rules.
When Private Fines ARE Enforceable
- The operator is a member of an accredited trade association (BPA or IPC).
- Adequate signage was displayed, clearly communicating the terms.
- The charge is proportionate and serves a legitimate interest.
- The POFA 2012 NtK requirements were fully met.
- The operator is willing to pursue the claim through county court.
When Private Fines Are NOT Enforceable
- The operator is not a BPA or IPC member.
- Signage was missing, unclear, or non-compliant.
- The NtK was served late or was incomplete.
- POFA requirements were not met.
- The charge is disproportionate.
- There were errors on the PCN.
The Practical Reality
Even when a charge is technically enforceable, many operators choose not to pursue it to court because the legal costs outweigh the charge. However, some operators — particularly ParkingEye and a few others — do regularly pursue court claims. You should not rely on the hope that they won't bother.
The Best Approach
If you have valid grounds, appeal. If the appeal process is exhausted and you have no grounds, consider paying to avoid a potential CCJ.
Generate Your Appeal Letter
Test the enforceability of your fine. Generate your personalised appeal letter in minutes with CancelMyFine — just £4.99. Visit CancelMyFine.co.uk for legal clarity and a strong appeal.