Broken Meter — A Valid Defence
If you received a parking fine because the meter or ticket machine was broken and you couldn't pay, you have strong grounds for appeal. It is unreasonable to penalise a driver who was willing to pay but unable to do so because of a faulty machine. This applies to both council PCNs and private parking charges.
What Evidence Do You Need?
- Photos of the broken machine: Photograph the machine showing any error messages, blank screens, or coin slot jams.
- Timestamp evidence: Your phone photos will have timestamp metadata proving when they were taken.
- Witness statements: If other drivers witnessed the broken machine, their statements can support your case.
- Proof you tried alternative methods: Show you attempted to use the app or tried other machines nearby.
Council PCN — Broken Meter Defence
For council PCNs, a broken meter is a recognised ground for formal representation. Under the Traffic Management Act 2004, if the contravention occurred because the meter was out of order through no fault of your own, and you took reasonable steps to pay, this is a valid defence. If the council rejects your representation, appeal to the Traffic Penalty Tribunal.
Private Parking — Broken Machine
For private parking charges, a broken machine means you couldn't comply with the terms even if you wanted to. This undermines the contractual basis of the charge. State in your appeal that you were willing to pay but the operator's equipment prevented you from doing so.
Generate Your Appeal Letter
Don't pay for someone else's broken machine. Generate your personalised appeal letter in minutes with CancelMyFine — just £4.99. Visit CancelMyFine.co.uk to appeal your fine.