Broken Machine — You Shouldn't Pay the Price
If you received a parking fine because the ticket machine, payment terminal, or parking meter was out of order, you have strong grounds for appeal. You cannot be expected to pay for parking when the operator's own equipment prevents you from doing so.
What to Do at the Time
If you arrive and find the machine broken, take these steps immediately:
- Photograph the machine showing error messages, blank screen, or damage.
- Try alternative payment: Check for nearby machines, contactless options, or parking apps.
- Leave a note on your dashboard explaining the machine was broken (photograph this too).
- Report the fault to the council or operator if possible — a phone call or email creates a record.
Council PCNs
For council-issued PCNs, a broken meter is a recognised statutory ground for appeal. The council should have a duty to maintain its equipment, and you should not be penalised for their failure to do so. If one machine was broken, the council may argue you should have used another — counter this by explaining the distance or noting other machines were also out of order.
Private Parking Charges
For private car parks, if the only payment method was a machine that was broken, there was no way for you to comply with the terms. This undermines the entire basis of the charge. If an app payment option existed, the operator may argue you should have used it — but only if this was clearly signposted.
Generate Your Appeal Letter
Broken machine, unfair fine. Generate your personalised appeal letter in minutes with CancelMyFine — just £4.99. Visit CancelMyFine.co.uk and let us help you appeal.